Let me preface by repeating one of the basic tenants of traditional wetshaving:
Your Milage May Vary
I've read multiple reviews of MdC online, several made by wetshavers whose judgement I trusts. The overwhelming view seems to be that MdC is an awesome soap in every way. Personally I can't see what the fuss is all about, less so given the high cost of it.
Yes, it is long lasting - but so are many of my other soaps.
Yes, it smells pretty nice - but so does many of my other soaps.
Yes, it makes great lather which cushions and provides great slip - but so does many of my other soaps.
No, it don't leave my face feeling dry - but neither do many of my other soaps.
Yes, it is an overall solid performer - but so does many of my other soaps.
And yes, it's costly - more so than many of my other soaps.
Perhaps my view on the McD would been different if I wasn't blessed with soft water, perhaps I would been more awestruck by it if I wasn't spoiled by a certain artisan soap maker...
Don't get me wrong; there is nothing wrong with McD - far from it. But to me at least the McD isn't so right I'll go out and buy more - I rather stock up on more of Mike's Natural Soaps which to me is just as good and comes in a lot more scents.
As I said, YMMV - but if you want to give McD a spin then do yourself a favour and get a sample first.